The recent news stories describing the massive layoffs at the International Mission Board of Southern Baptists, the nearly 50% downsizing of the Florida Baptist Convention staff, the continued erosion of financial support for the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship, and the sell-off by state conventions of facilities now too large for shrunken staff, all confirm what is becoming obvious.
We are witnessing the beginning of the end for Baptist denominational entities, as we have known them. Following the lead of mainline judicatories, Baptist bodies, local, state, regional and national, are in free-fall.
Not surprisingly, the primary culprit is a decline in funding from local churches. As traditional churches have struggled to attract attenders and funds in the 21st century, more and more of their resources are kept at home to pay bills, employ staff, do local ministry, etc. The ensuing reduction of funds to local, state and national bodies has led to a funding crisis unlike anything these entities have ever known.
In Southern Baptist life, many local Associations no longer can afford staff, and those who do are operating at a minimal level. Consolidation and mergers with neighboring groups are the norm.
Declining receipts from churches and increasing pressure from the national body to forward a larger percentage of receipts up-stream are squeezing state conventions and associations. The result is massive “reorganizations” and huge reductions in staff and services. Most state conventions/associations have reduced their staff by 33-50% since 2000. As reserves are exhausted, those contractions will only increase.
The national SBC similarly reports discouraging numbers, with last year seeing the lowest receipts since 1990, and the largest decline in attendance in 130 years. Recent years have seen huge layoffs occurring at the NAMB and the IMB.
The Cooperative Baptist Fellowship fares even worse, with receipts last year of $12.4m, compared to $16.9m in 2000. That decrease, combined with a 38.5% inflation rate over those years, means a financial position that has been reduced by nearly 50%.
As denominational mission boards have radically scaled back on appointing fully-funded missionaries (CBF has not appointed a fully funded new missionary since 2006, and many IMB missionaries are self-funded), the obvious result has been that those self-funded missionaries appeal to local churches and church members for support. Add to that the strategy of encouraging churches to adopt and support financially individual missionaries, areas, and specific mission projects, and the cannibalizing of congregational support has had its inevitable impact. More dollars directly to missionaries and customized projects means fewer dollars to the denomination.
The ensuing feeding frenzy for limited dollars in local church budgets is met with a less-than-enthusiastic response from stressed pastors and finance committees. The appeals bring to mind the onerous days of “societal giving”, in which various entities compete for limited dollars and attention from local churches. Frustration with that system led, of course, to the creation of The Cooperative Program in 1925.
Clearly, American churches are entering the last stages of the “Institutional Denominational Era” that has dominated much of American religious life since the early 20th century. As we do, local, state and national denominational bodies will play an increasingly smaller role in the life of local churches. The erosion of their services and support will have a significant impact on the life of local congregations.
Some of those include:
- Those congregations who have depended upon denominational bodies to provide a vision to guide their work and approach to ministry will soon find themselves adrift without clear plans or strategies.
- Training and teaching events will continue to diminish.
- When churches do ask denominational bodies for help, the help will often be subpar, or will simply be a referral to another entity, usually with a price tag attached.
- Local churches of all persuasions will increasingly grow independent and even non-denominational without the denominational bodies to hold them together.
- Affinity groups will exert an increasing influence upon churches that find more relevant and quality help from them (Leadership Network, Willow Creek Network, Catalyst, Habitat for Humanity, The Center for Healthy Churches, etc.) than from their denominational bodies.
- A new era of entrepreneurship and innovation will emerge as congregations cast off denominational boundaries and explore creative solutions to pressing issues.
- Denominational appeals and pressure upon local church giving will amp up as funds continue to decrease.
- Traditional churches will continue to close with regularity, even as church planting continues to expand.
- Lean, effective, and innovative groups will emerge who provide effective help to congregations.
The critical question remaining unanswered: Will the surviving bits and pieces of denominational bodies coalesce into helpful and relevant sources of help and guidance to old and new congregations and the missionary enterprise? As we anticipate thousands of local churches closing in the next 20 years, and many thousands of new church plants beginning, all inundated by missionaries looking for support, we need to recognize that a fundamental shift in congregational life is underway.
Will denominational bodies be able to morph into a valuable resource for those who survive? The odds appear long for most of them. Lean, visionary, future-focused and humble denominational bodies at least have a chance.