Navigating pastoral transitions is a crucial and often challenging process for churches. With decades of experience as a pastor, a father of a minister, and an advisor to hundreds of ministerial search teams, I’ve witnessed firsthand the impact of both successful and flawed transitions.
Nearly every congregational conflict CHC has encountered in the past 20 years can be traced back to issues within the pastoral search process. This makes it essential for churches to follow healthy, strategic, and prayerful practices when selecting a new leader.
While no two transitions are identical, they often follow similar patterns and best practices. Below are some key lessons that can help guide ministerial search teams through this process.
12 Key Lessons for Ministerial Search Teams
1. Recognize That This Is a Spiritual Discernment Process
Calling a pastor is not like hiring for a corporate job—it is a spiritual journey. Approach it with prayer, humility, and discernment, embracing the Prayer of Holy Indifference to set aside personal biases. Establish a Team Covenant to ensure consensus, trust, and accountability
2. Set Aside Personal Agendas
Every team member has personal preferences, but this process is about God’s agenda for the church. Focus on what is best for the congregation’s long-term health, not individual desires.
3. Be Honest About Your Church’s Current Situation
No church is perfect. Be transparent with candidates about the gap between who your church is today and who it aspires to be. Authenticity fosters trust and alignment.
4. Avoid Treating This Like a Corporate Search
A pastoral search is unique—it is not the same as hiring for a business, hospital, or school. Put aside corporate hiring tactics and focus on spiritual leadership qualities.
5. Don’t Rely on Past Search Experiences
If you’ve been through this process before, resist the urge to compare or share “war stories.” The ministerial search landscape has changed dramatically—adapt to new realities and best practices.
6. Create Thoughtful Church & Minister Profiles
A well-crafted Church Profile and Next Pastor Profile are essential. Clearly define your church’s identity, needs, and vision to attract the right candidates. Match candidates to the needs and opportunities stated in your profile.
7. Prioritize Emotional, Spiritual & Missional Intelligence
Beyond resumes, look for candidates with strong Emotional Intelligence (EQ), Spiritual Intelligence (SQ), and Missional Intelligence (MQ). These qualities define healthy, effective ministers.
8. Cultivate Humility Within the Search Team
The more confident you are in your own abilities, the more likely you are to fail. Humility is a key predictor of success—trust the process and seek divine guidance.
9. Move Beyond Resumes Quickly
A great resume doesn’t always equal a great pastor. Shift your focus to leadership qualities, character, and spiritual maturity that align with your church’s needs.
10. Remember That Pastoral Impact Happens Beyond the Pulpit
Preaching is important, but a truly beloved and effective pastor makes their greatest impact between Sundays—through relationships, leadership, and pastoral care.
11. Seek Consensus on Your Final Candidate
Not every team member will feel equally enthusiastic, but unity is key. Ensure that all members can stand before the church with integrity and support for the final selection.
12. Focus on Humility, Character & Competence
The best predictor of pastoral success is not age, education, or charisma. It is a blend of humility, Christ-like character, and leadership competence. Prioritize these, and trust that God will bless the outcome.
Final Thoughts
A successful ministerial search is not about finding a perfect pastor—it’s about discerning God’s will for your church’s next season. By following spiritual principles, best practices, and a thoughtful process, your search team can help identify a faithful, effective leader for years to come.
Would you like additional resources or guidance on your pastoral search process? Let’s continue the conversation! The Center for Healthy Churches has many experienced consultants who can assist your search from while serving as an interim pastor, or as a coach to your search team even if you use a trusted interim of your choosing. Contact us today to explore your options.
Leave a Reply